Welcome to Baked by Luigi
Baked by Luigi, located in NYC, offers a variety of traditional and signature pizzas like Margherita, Meatylicious, and White Pizza. The cozy atmosphere with art events adds to the dining experience. Customers rave about the perfect balance of crispy crust, sauce, and toppings. Luigi's warm and friendly personality enhances the dining experience, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. The menu also includes sandwiches like the chicken Parm and meat raviolis, loved for their flavors and quality. Overall, Baked by Luigi is praised for its delicious pizza, welcoming vibe, and exceptional service.
-
221 E 23rd St New York, NY 10010 Hotline: (646) 454-0045
Baked by Luigi is a renowned pizza, Italian, and sandwich restaurant located in New York City. Boasting a wide range of menu options, this establishment offers classic NY cheese pizzas, traditional Sicilian pizzas, and a variety of specialty pies such as the Margherita, Grandma, and Veggielicious pizzas.
With a focus on quality ingredients and delicious flavor combinations, Baked by Luigi has earned a loyal following of customers who rave about the perfect crust, abundance of toppings, and friendly service. The restaurant also offers a range of amenities like delivery, takeout, outdoor seating, and free Wi-Fi, making it a convenient and enjoyable dining experience for all.
Customers have praised the signature pizzas like the Nicolo Special with fennel sausage, caramelized onions, and ricotta cheese, as well as the Baby Brussel Sprouts and Bacon pizza for its unique and flavorful combination. The reviews highlight the warmth and hospitality of Luigi, the owner, who adds a personal touch to every visit.
If you're looking for a cozy spot to enjoy mouthwatering pizza and sandwiches, Baked by Luigi is the place to be. Whether you're a fan of classic flavors or looking to try something new, this restaurant offers a diverse menu to satisfy every palate. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in the heart of New York City – your taste buds will thank you!
Decent pizza with a good vibe! Food: we got a few slices of the pizza (white, pepperoni, and buffalo chicken)! They were all good! The pepperoni one apparently is known as 'pepperoni crack'! I thought the pizza slices were fine but nothing too special Price: for the quality I did think it was very pricey- with each slice being a bit over $5 Service: I really liked the shop owner! He was very funny and told us how he hosts art events at the pizza shop - which is very cool! Ambience: has some art and written out sticky notes which is very cool
This is really truly fabulous pizza. Initially I went to try a chicken Parm sandwich which honestly was just ok - a little wet and didn't come with the lettuce and tomatoes indicated in the menu, although I have to say the bread was excellent. I had to go back to try the pizza, and I'm so glad I did. The cheese slice ce may be my favorite in town. Perfectly gooey with a light flakey crust that gives that signature snap when you bite into it. Love, love, love. It's become our weekly pizza spot. The meat raviolis and garlic knots are also a must. (You may want to sit down before trying the knots - they'll make you go weak in the knees.)
Omg - the pizza here is perfect- crust is crunchy and chewy, perfect amount of sauce and cheese and pep ratio. This pizza is total fire.
The BEST pizza, and Luigi is THE NICEST GUY EVER. He is warm, funny, and makes a mean pie. I love their truffle mushroom white pizza and also the one with baked eggplant. But even a simple marghertia slice transcends the palate. They also stay open late and don't have too many choices like a large dollar slice shop, but that means everything you see gets made fresh and nothing has been sitting out all day. Thank you Luigi for bringing your magic to Gramercy!
Stopped here after a show at the gramercy theater. Not too much selection as it was close to closing. The pizza was ok to me but the dude is awesome and had a fun time while waiting. Had a cheese, supreme, margarite, and pepperoni. No real stand out and just don't think ny style pizza is my thing. Went to joes and thought the same thing. Just can't beat Napoli pizza. But get you a slice and get the f$$k outta here haha.
I'm glad I found this place! There's no decent pizza near me and I'm exploring my options. This is less than 10 min drive away so I gave it a try. The crust is okay, I like it more chewy but this is better than most places around. The mozzarella is a bit overcooked though. I'd definitely give it another try.
I ordered on a Saturday night at around 9pm (Feb -3rd) DELIVERY The mozzarella nuggets and grandma pizza before were great. Super happy that they're in the neighborhood however last night I ordered a pizza and I don't know if they have their own delivery people or if they hire delivery from a third-party but the pizza looks like it was shot out of a canon , still good though just a mess to eat and not what you expect to see when you open the pizza box.
Hands down my favorite pizza in town. I always take family visiting from out of town here when they want a good slice. Aunts, cousins, it's never disappointed. Perfect combination of things. Crispy yet chewy, light and airy, and so damn flavorful. And Luigi is just a really nice dude. Ribs you on a bit and so genuine. When you hear the kind of conversations that take place here you can tell this place is beloved by the locals. I am one of these locals. And yes, I love it.